Readers Debate Spicy Scenes Fuel Romantasy Obsession
From the princes and princesses of folk tales to Emma Bull’s 1987 Irish mythology-inspired War for the Oaks, romance in fantasy fiction has existed as long as dragons, faeries, and elves have. However, “romantasy” as a literary genre has rarely seen the success it enjoys today, generating nearly $1 billion in US book sales in 2025. Its popularity grew massively through BookTok and Bookstagram, the colloquial names for online reader communities. As more and more people embrace the genre, a debate has emerged over what makes it so appealing. Many argue that the steamy encounters increasingly associated with popular romantasy titles are the main draw. Others claim that reducing the genre’s success to its “spicy” content overlooks the worldbuilding, complex characters, political intrigue, and emotional stakes. As readers keep debating, bestselling romantasy author Tricia O’Malley, known for





